• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Poetry Catalog

We honor great poets. We honor great poetry.

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Submit Your Work
  • Writers
  • Advertising / Subscription

Best Friend’s Sister, By: Andrew Cyr

March 7, 2024 by Andrew Cyr

Best Friend's Sister, By: Andrew Cyr

Natalia, my best friend’s sister, weaved
through my thoughts.
Opposite reasons collided
with logic like an instrument
with a darker purpose.
Natalia’s growth caught my
attention until lust warmed
her presence.
Come hell as it will,
I had to have Natalia.
I spilled a confession.
Pure love guided me
through a dancefloor
of excuses.
Mark’s family lived next door.
We’d been best friends since
we crawled out of the womb.
Our last school
year fell upon us,
and his sister
started college.
I was 18.
Natalia was 19.
As a kid, she was knees and elbows.
Nothing attracted me to Natalia.
She’s the crush my insecurity pushed away.
I teased her because I knew she’d never date me.
But when she arrived home for winter break,
I did a double-take.
Natalia’s chest and hips filled out.
Her oval green eyes captivated
my gaze, drawing me in only
if she knew how.
The names I called her
washed across my face.
Mark asked my sister
on a date before either
of us knew anything about me,
pulling an emergency
parachute for a soft landing.
No one would have guessed
I’d fall for Natalia, not me.
Natalia played hard to get,
but I played harder.
I asked her once about seeing
a flick.
Natalia tucked her long, blonde
bangs behind her ear,
leaving it an open question.
My parents traveled to New York
and left me here in Seattle.
The day drained me,
and I closed my eyes
as darkness cloaked
the sky over a sliver moon.
The rain rattled the windows,
rolling off the tin roof.
A knock at the door startled me
like lightning in a jar.
I shot upright and pushed my feet
into my slippers.
I fished under my bed, grabbed a bat,
and approached the door.
I flipped on the porch light.
Natalia stood.
Her arms looped around
her waist.
I swallowed hard.
Her mascara trailed her cheeks
with the raindrops hitting her face.
“Gonna invite me in?” Natalia said, wiping her face and laughing through tears.
“Only if you promise to come into my life and never leave,” I said.
Natalia blushed. “Deal.”

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest

Related

Filed Under: Poems

Get Every Post In Your Inbox 😳

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
(This is not the newsletter.)

Primary Sidebar

Never Miss A Poem (Newsletter)

Be Social

  • X
  • Facebook

Top Posts & Pages

  • Written In Durham, By: Matt Morris Hawkins
    Written In Durham, By: Matt Morris Hawkins
  • Art On Paper, By: Mary Bone
    Art On Paper, By: Mary Bone
  • I Could Stay Lost, By: Mary Bone
    I Could Stay Lost, By: Mary Bone
  • Life Inside My Snow Globe, By: Mary Bone
    Life Inside My Snow Globe, By: Mary Bone
  • Spring Clippings, By: Mary Bone
    Spring Clippings, By: Mary Bone
  • Prayer Mats, By: Mary Bone
    Prayer Mats, By: Mary Bone
  • The Mimic, By: Mary Bone
    The Mimic, By: Mary Bone
  • Busy Days, By: Samuel Okereke
    Busy Days, By: Samuel Okereke
  • Filled, By: Erin Jamieson
    Filled, By: Erin Jamieson
  • Duckfeet, By: Mary Bone
    Duckfeet, By: Mary Bone

Advertising/Subscribing = Loving

Buy Me A Coffee

Sign up for the newsletter. Get a gift.

Footer

Made with ❤ in Lubbock, TX.

Poetry Catalog Sponsors

Haiku Examples

Search

Copyright © 2025 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in