Who decides what is "sane"? In eight sharp lines, Emily Dickinson argues that the majority labels anyone who disagrees as dangerous. A great poem for teaching paradox and for debates about conformity. This free worksheet has the full poem with numbered lines, vocabulary, five discussion questions, a writing prompt and an answer key. No signup needed.
Grades 9–12 · Common Core RL.9-10.4, RL.9-10.2, RL.9-10.6 · US Letter PDF, with an answer key on the last page
What’s on the worksheet
Dickinson wrote the poem around 1862; it was published in 1890. She lived an unusual, private life, and many neighbors thought her strange. The poem is built on paradoxes: statements that seem to contradict themselves but reveal a truth.
Vocabulary
- divinest: most holy or wise
- discerning: able to judge well, perceptive
- starkest: most complete, total
- majority: the larger number of people
- prevails: wins, rules
- assent: agree
- demur: object, disagree
- straightway: immediately
Discussion questions
- Explain the paradox in the first three lines.
- What kind of person can see that "madness" may be "divinest sense"?
- Who decides what counts as sane, according to the poem?
- What happens to someone who will "Demur"?
- Can you think of a person in history who was called mad or dangerous but was later proved right?
Writing prompt
Write a short poem (6–10 lines) built on a paradox, such as "the loudest silence" or "the bravest fear," that reveals a truth about people.
The answer key is included in the PDF, on its own page for teachers.